Robert Young, MD dissects a Mother Jones hit piece aimed at the NRA in his latest National Review Online article. Read more…
Doctors Can Be Wrong
Robert B. Young, MD
The American Academy of Pediatrics doesn’t have the facts about children and gun safety. Read more at National Review Online…
Serious gun accidents among children have fallen as gun ownership has risen. Read more at National Review Online…
August 22, 2014 Robert B. Young, MD on doctors dispensing “gun safety” advice outside their area of expertise http://www.nranews.com/cam/video/dr-robert-young-doctors-should-advise-on-medicine-not-guns
August 15, 2014 Robert B. Young, MD on Florida’s Docs vs Glocks law: http://www.nranews.com/cam/video/dr-robert-young-docs-glocks-and-patients/list/cam-and-co-feature
by Robert B. Young, MD
Robin Williams’ gift to the public was being the world’s wittiest improvisational comic and a heartfelt actor. He could ad-lib jokes in a spontaneous stream that kept us in stitches and in awe, and move us emotionally with gentle humor on screen. He had been reported to have bipolar disorder. He had referred to his own inner demons, depression and drug abuse. His struggles and death are illuminating in several ways.
Bipolar disorder is characterized by spontaneous, major mood shifts from too high (mania) to too low (depression). When manic one enjoys it, speaks and lives fast, sleeps less, but may use poor judgment and take more risks. When depressed, one is in despair and may be immobilized with no capacity to experience emotions other than hopelessness. There is a greater liability to drug abuse and dependence, particularly of alcohol, and among drug addicts there are more of these mood disorders than in general. Mr. Williams evidently experienced all that.
One of his self-descriptions became the “sad clown” (for those of a certain age, think Emmett Kelly). That is very apt, depicting a performer who brings joy and release to others yet can’t escape his own misery. Those two states can coexist in a sufferer sometimes, as a bipolar “mixed state”. This usually means the person shows manic behaviors while experiencing depression within. One wonders how often this was Mr. Williams’ experience.
There were likely personal stresses triggering his end, perhaps overreacting to early Parkinson’s disease. However, people with serious mood disorders like bipolar, especially with drug dependence, alcohol abuse or both, are all at increased risk during their lifetimes for suicide. Nearly all who kill themselves do so in the grip of acute psychiatric states that would have been treatable.
From his death, there are other lessons to be learned. Talent and success, fame and fortune are no defense against psychiatric illness or tragic responses to it. They can even impede good treatment, because of the image celebrities uphold of leading idealized lives. Public expectations don’t accommodate private anguish. Mr. Williams reportedly was dealing with severe depression recently, as at other times through his life. Evidently self-inflicted cuts express how severe his emotional pain must have been. He then hanged himself with a belt in his own closet. It happened at night, after a normal goodbye to his wife, when no one would be expected for hours. There was serious intent to die, even if it was unexpected.
It’s good if guns were not accessible to Mr. Williams as he was “battling severe depression”. But though guns are lethal tools for suicide, there are many other ways to accomplish it. Any of us, wherever we are and whatever we are doing, could easily kill ourselves in a variety of ways. Well people don’t because it just doesn’t occur to us. When someone truly intends to die, they can and simply do.
I daresay that mainstream media would have blamed the gun too if Mr. Williams had used one, with less attention to the more significant, complex realities of depression, suicide, and his life and struggles. But his belt and the closet are being ignored! Let’s not blame the method, so let’s not ban belts, closets, razors – or guns. Let’s intervene to keep people safe when there is cause for concern, to give them the one more chance that could be their turning point.
– Robert B. Young, MD is a psychiatrist in private practice in Pittsford, NY, and a clinical associate professor at the University of Rochester School of Medicine.
By Robert B. Young, MD
A three judge panel of the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 on July 25 that the Florida state law popularly called “Docs vs. Glocks” is indeed constitutional…read more at the Herald-Tribune’s blog, The Gun Writer…
Dr. Young in the Washington Times—Stalkers Don’t Stop, But Arming Victims Would Help
The surest safeguard against an obsessed admirer is a gun…read more .
A doctor defended himself and others from a violent patient, but he had to break a no-gun policy to do so.
‘More might have died if doctor had not shot gunman” — so read the headline in the Philadelphia Inquirer on July 27. On the previous Thursday, a patient, Richard Plotts, entered the office of his psychiatrist, Lee Silverman, M.D., with his caseworker, Theresa Hunt. Plotts then became very upset and killed Hunt with two shots to her head. While this was happening, Dr. Silverman tried to take cover, drew his handgun, and shot the attacker three times. The doctor suffered slight wounds from bullets that grazed his head and hit his thumb. Staffers then succeeded in subduing the wounded Plotts. He was hospitalized in critical condition and now faces murder charges.
District attorney Jack Whelan said: “If Dr. Silverman did not have the firearm and did not utilize the firearm, he’d be dead today. And other people would be dead.” In fact, the doctor had breached the facility’s “no firearms” policy by carrying a weapon with him to work. The facility released a statement saying that it looked forward to his “return to serving patients at our hospital.”
Plotts had a previous record of violence, including suicide attempts, and he has been involuntarily committed twice to psychiatric care, most recently last year. He was a convicted felon, with two gun-related convictions, and he had served time in prison for bank robbery. His violent behavior had led a local homeless shelter to ban him, and he had caused previous trouble at the hospital. In another article, Plotts’s ex-wife described him as abusive and violent, and she also has said that she remains afraid of him 15 years after their divorce. What was he doing with a firearm? Oh, of course: It was illegal. Convicted felons are prohibited by law from owning a weapon.Theresa Hunt, by all accounts, was a dedicated, caring woman who made it her life’s mission to help those in need of mental-health care and social services. She recognized the risk she faced from unstable patients. She probably died instantly.
In deciding to carry a loaded handgun at his workplace, Dr. Silverman judged that he would be wise to ignore the hospital’s no-guns policy. No one should fault him for this. Perhaps he recognized that it was more important to protect lives than to trust in the false promises of safety offered by “gun-free zones.” Every year mental-health professionals are assaulted by clients, and some are killed. Psychiatrists are the physicians most likely to encounter unpredictably dangerous patients. With the exception of threats and one knock-down, I have been spared so far. But I do know a colleague whose patient shot himself dead in the psychiatrist’s office, and a patient of mine slashed her throat in the waiting room of my clinic. Contrast Dr. Silverman’s experience with that of Kathryn Faughey and Kent Shinbach, two doctors who were unarmed when attacked by a delusional schizophrenic patient in 2008. In that assault, Dr. Faughey was killed and Dr. Shinbech was injured.
The hospital’s announcement that it will welcome Dr. Silverman back once he recovers is amazing compared with the usual treatment of employees who choose self-defense over death and end up being fired for breaching no-gun rules. Dr. Silverman and the staffers exercised a good dose of ordinary, self-preserving common sense — and in doing so they became extraordinary heroes.
Another element of this tragedy, one to which all physicians can relate, is that doctors are taught, first and foremost, the golden rule of medicine: “Do no harm.” It would be a particular grief for a physician to have to harm or kill a patient intentionally. We hope never to have to respond to any patient with anything but care and compassion. But that may not be possible, or right, when a patient is the cause of harm.
Responsible people do right by themselves and, especially, others. Is it possible that we are finally coming to understand that doing right can include using guns, too?
— Robert B. Young, M.D., is a private psychiatrist in Pittsford, N.Y., and a clinical associate professor at the University of Rochester School of Medicine.